Xj. Capdevila et al., OCCLUSION PRESSURE AND ITS RATIO TO MAXIMUM INSPIRATORY PRESSURE ARE USEFUL PREDICTORS FOR SUCCESSFUL EXTUBATION FOLLOWING T-PIECE WEANING TRIAL, Chest, 108(2), 1995, pp. 482-489
Study objective: In most weaning studies, failure group patients are r
eventilated prior to extubation, thus compromising the evaluation of t
he applied weaning indices' predictive values. This study determines t
he usefulness of both standard and recent indices in predicting succes
sful extubation following prolonged mechanical ventilation. Design and
methods: Following a successful 20-min T-piece trial ten traditional
weaning criteria, as well as airway occlusion pressure (PO.1), maximal
inspiratory pressure (MIP),PO.1/MIP ratio, and shallow breathing (F/V
T were determined in unselected patients undergoing prolonged mechanic
al ventilation. Having satisfied 8 of 10 classic weaning criteria, 67
patients were extubated after an additional 40 min of successful spont
aneous T-piece breathing, and included in the study. After extubation,
the tracheal tube resistive pressure (RP) values were measured. Resul
ts: Twelve (18%) patients failed extubation. The failure group's avera
ge age was significantly greater (69.43 vs 48.43 years). The PO.1, PO.
1/MIP, and F/VT values of the success (3.62+/-1.35 cm H2O, 0.05+/-0.04
, and 50+/-23 b . min(-1). L(-1) and failure (7.38+/-2.67 cm H2O, 0.14
+/-0.04, and 69+/-25 b . min(-1). L(-1) groups were significantly diff
erent (p<0.005). The diagostic accuracies of these indices were, respe
ctively, 88%, 98%, and 73%. The spirometric, gas exchange, and trachea
l tube RP values of the two groups showed no significant differences.
Conclusion: PO.1 and PO.1/MIP ratio provide the best means of predicti
ng extubation success, and they are not influenced by tracheal tube re
sistance.