1. A number of mechanistic possibilities exist for P450-catalysed N-de
alkylation and have been considered over the years, including C- and N
-hydroxylation and sequential electron transfer (SET). With peroxidase
s the evidence strongly favours SET and free radicals can be detected.
Any mechanism must account for lack of incorporation of label from (H
2O)-O-18 into product by P450s and the high kinetic deuterium isotope
effects that are seen in N-dealkylation reactions catalysed by peroxid
ases but not P450s. 2. Several lines of evidence support a role for SE
T in P450 amine oxidations, including Hammett analysis, products of di
hydropyridine oxidations, and products of mechanism-based inhibition b
y strained cycloalkylamines. 3. The hypothesis was considered that the
P450s act via base catalysis to deprotonate the aminium radical gener
ated by SET, since the pK(a), has been estimated to be similar to 9. D
ihydropyridine aminium radicals have low pK(a), (<4) and are generally
considered to have considerable kinetic acidity. None of the haemopro
teins under consideration (including the peroxidases and haemoglobin)
showed high kinetic hydrogen isotope effects for the oxidation of [4-H
-2]- or [4-H-3]-labelled 1,4-dihydropyridines. These results are conso
nant with the view that P450s catalyse the deprotonation of N,N-dialky
laniline aminium radicals. 4. Since low isotope effects were seen with
biomimetic metalloporphyrin models as well as P450s, the deprotonatio
n is attributed to the (FeO)(2+) entity, expected to be a strong base,
and not the apoprotein. Thus, the FeO moiety of peroxidases is shield
ed, consistent with evidence by others that SET occurs through the por
phyrin edge. Both P450s and peroxidases catalysed the oxidative N-deme
thylation of aminopyrine and N,N-dimethylaminothioanisole; however, on
ly the peroxidases generated the stable coloured aminium radicals. 5.
The rates of N-demethylation of variously para-substituted N,N-dimethy
lanilines can be used to undertake Hammett or Marcus analysis. The for
mer yields rho = -0.6 and the latter an apparent E(1/2) of similar to
1.8 for the formal (FeO)(3+) entity of P4502B1. 6. Even in the oxidati
on of N,N-dialkylanilines, a finite rate of N-oxidation is seen (simil
ar to 0.1% of N-dealkylation). The simplest paradigm has N-oxygenation
and N-dealkylation both proceeding from a common aminium radical inte
rmediate.