Ev. Teodorovich, SMALL-SCALE INTERMITTENCY IN RANDOMLY STIRRED FLUIDS - COMMENT, Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics, 52(2), 1995, pp. 2118-2118
We feel that the paper under consideration [M. Nandy, Phys. Rev. E 48,
1015 (1993)] contains some inaccuracies regarding the dimensional ana
lysis used in the discussion of the corrections to Kolmogorov scaling
laws. Our remarks are as follows. (i) Incorrect diagram equations have
been used under the dimensional self-consistency analysis. (ii) from
the hydrodynamic Ward identity it follows that a scale dimension of th
e vertex is canonical. (iii) Simple dimensionality arguments are inval
id when integrals in diagram equations contain divergences, as it is f
or Kolmogorov's case. (iv) A multiplicative velocity renormalization i
s inconsistent with Dyson diagram equations.