D. Altmark et al., PARTIAL INSANITY - WHEN THE JUDICIARY AND THE PSYCHIATRIC WORLD COLLIDE, Israel journal of psychiatry and related sciences, 32(2), 1995, pp. 109-113
The psychiatric and judicial concepts of mental disorders are similar
but not always identical. The gap between them creates confusion, a la
ck of unity and inconsistencies in decision making. This gap needs to
be bridged. In the hinterland of these concepts lies a range of psychi
atric disturbances such as encapsulated over organized delusional diso
rders (Paranoia Vera) and life endangering eating disorders (Anorexia
Nervosa). When life threatening or criminal responsibility circumstanc
es arise, the dilemma presented to the psychiatrists on the one hand a
nd the judicial system on the other reaches its peak. Presented in the
article are aspects of the gray areas of involuntary commitment and c
riminal responsibility.