Although phacoemulsification with only topical anaesthesia is possible
, the level of any discomfort perceived by the patient is unknown. Top
ical anaesthesia eliminates any risk of inadvertent ocular or orbital
injury. Twenty-four patients undergoing phacoemulsification under only
topical anaesthesia (g. amethocaine 1%) were compared with 23 patient
s undergoing the same procedure with peribulbar anaesthesia (5 mi lign
ocaine 2%, 5 mi bupivacaine 0.5% and 75 units hyaluronidase). Perceive
d pain on administration of the anaesthesia, per-operatively and post-
operatively was assessed by a nursing officer using a visual analogue
scale (0-10). It was found that there was no difference in pain score
between the two groups on induction of anaesthesia. Per-operatively an
d post-operatively scores were higher in the topical group than in the
peribulbar group (p < 0.05, Mann-Whitney U-test), though most of thes
e were within the range 0-3, ('no pain' to 'slight pain'). There was n
o difference in the amount of analgesia dispensed to the two groups on
the ward post-operatively. In conclusion, topical anaesthesia provide
s adequate anaesthesia for phacoemulsification, Although a small incre
ase in the level of discomfort was observed, the pain levels reported
were small and may not be clinically significant when set against the
reduced incidence of anaesthetic-related complications.