Me. Whitcomb et Rs. Miller, PARTICIPATION OF INTERNATIONAL MEDICAL GRADUATES IN GRADUATE MEDICAL-EDUCATION AND HOSPITAL-CARE FOR THE POOR, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 274(9), 1995, pp. 696-699
Objective.-To determine the impact of limiting international medical g
raduate (IMG) participation in US graduate medical education (GME) on
the delivery of hospital care to the poor. Methods.-To ascertain the p
attern of IMG participation in GME and the degree to which the princip
al teaching hospitals with programs with large IMG enrollments provide
care to the poor, we used data from the American Medical Association
1993 Annual Survey of Graduate Medical Education Programs and Teaching
Institutions to analyze the pattern of IMG participation in GME in th
e six core specialties of internal medicine, family practice, obstetri
cs and gynecology, surgery, pediatrics, and psychiatry. Main Outcome M
easures.-Programs were identified as IMG dependent if at least 50% of
the resident physicians enrolled in the first year of the program were
IMGs. All programs were linked to their principal teaching hospitals,
and hospitals were assessed according to the number of programs based
at each institution, the number of IMG-dependent programs at the inst
itution, and whether no-pay patients and/or Medicaid/public assistance
beneficiaries constituted more than 20% of the patients served. Resul
ts.-Of the 20 170 first-year resident physicians in the six core speci
alties, 31.8% were IMGs. The proportion of programs dependent on IMG e
nrollment was 27.7%, ranging from 5.2% in obstetrics and gynecology pr
ograms to 49.5% in psychiatry programs. About 72% of all first-year IM
Gs were in IMG-dependent programs. Of the 688 hospitals serving as pri
ncipal teaching sites for programs in at least one of the six core spe
cialties, 106 were categorized as dependent on IMG programs, but only
77 of those provided a disproportionate amount of care to the poor. Fi
nally, 40% of IMG-dependent GME programs and 36% of first-year IMG res
idents were based in hospitals that did not provide a disproportionate
amount of care to the poor. Conclusions.-Based on this analysis, 77 h
ospitals can arguably be considered dependent on IMG resident physicia
ns to provide care to the poor. Moreover, a large number of IMG reside
nts and IMG-dependent programs are in hospitals that do not provide a
disproportionate amount of care to the poor. These findings show the s
cale of the problem policymakers must address if they choose to limit
IMG access to GME while maintaining access of the poor to needed hospi
tal care.