SUBMERGED WALKING IN THE EPAULETTE SHARK HEMISCYLLIUM-OCELLATUM (HEMISCYLLIDAE) AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR LOCOMOTION IN RHIPIDISTIAN FISHES AND EARLY TETRAPODS
Pa. Pridmore, SUBMERGED WALKING IN THE EPAULETTE SHARK HEMISCYLLIUM-OCELLATUM (HEMISCYLLIDAE) AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR LOCOMOTION IN RHIPIDISTIAN FISHES AND EARLY TETRAPODS, Zoology, 98(4), 1994, pp. 278-297
The small reef-dwelling orectolobiform shark Hemiscyllium ocellatum us
es both sets of paired fins to walk over submerged substrates. On flat
, horizontal surfaces, the diagonal fin-pairs function almost in synch
rony, with each pelvic fin being activated slightly ahead of the contr
alateral pectoral fin. This yields a gait close to a walking trot. As
with extant tetrapods, the durations of both the locomotor cycle and i
ts contact phase decrease with increasing locomotor speed. Unlike exta
nt tetrapods, the phase relations of ipsilateral paired appendages do
not vary with speed, but the pectoral fins remain around 0.6 of a cycl
e out of phase with the pelvics. Bottom-walking in Hemiscyllium is ass
ociated with waves of lateral bending of the body axis. In slow walkin
g, lateral bending is more pronounced at the head than the tail. With
increasing walking speed, there is a marked increase in bending in the
terminal portion of the tail. Fast walking gives way to a mode of pro
gression that is transitional to swimming at higher speeds. During sub
merged walking, both girdle relation and rotation of the paired fins a
bout their girdles contribute to stride. Preliminary measurements indi
cate that rotation of the pectoral girdle contributes between 65% and
95% of each stride, whereas pelvic-girdle rotation contributes only 15
-30%. The remainder of each stride comes from rotations of the paired
fins on their girdles. Modeling the vertical forces operating on a ''s
tandard'' quadruped that progresses using a slow-walking-trot indicate
s that this gait is unstable in a terrestrial environment. However, if
such an animal is submerged, its effective weight is greatly reduced
and the drag forces resisting toppling are much increased; thus, stati
c instability does not present a serious problem. Moreover, because He
miscyllium ocellatum has an elongate tail, the animal's centre of mass
lies posterior to its pelvis. Because the tail serves as a fifth supp
ort, H. ocellatum is statically, as well as dynamically, stable throug
hout the locomotor cycle when it uses a gait close to a slow-walking-t
rot in water. When removed from water and placed on a sandpaper-covere
d horizontal substrate, individuals of H. ocellatum progressed effecti
vely using a similar mode of walking. Data from non-teleost fishes on
the relationship between the length of propulsive waves used during sw
imming and the distance separating the pectoral and pelvic girdles, su
ggest that if rhipidistian fishes undertook submerged walking and if t
heir progression was generated substantially through lateral undulatio
ns of the body axis, they likely would have used a walking trot. Such
data also support the suggestion that rhipidistians might have activat
ed their paired fins in a trotlike pattern if they undertook overland
journeys, even though this may have been statically unstable. Several
lines of evidence suggest that submerged walking in early amphibians p
robably was achieved using a walking-trot. For terrestrial locomotion,
the situation is more complicated. If most early amphibians were prop
ortioned like Ichthyostega, overland progression with the body lifted
above the ground would have been ineffective, unless the ability to ac
tivate the paired appendages in a lateral sequence had already been ac
quired. For longer-tailed forms like Acanthostega, stable overland pro
gression using a walking-trot may have been possible. It is difficult
to determine when tetrapods (or their immediate ancestors) first becam
e capable of using both the lateral sequence walk and trot. However, i
f all Late Devonian amphibians prove to be very similar in their trunk
proportions, Australian trackways of this age would provide evidence
for such capability. Less equivocal evidence for the two gaits is prov
ided by Late Carboniferous trackways from North America.