Dk. Martin et al., FETAL TISSUE-TRANSPLANTATION AND ABORTION DECISIONS - A SURVEY OF URBAN WOMEN, CMAJ. Canadian Medical Association journal, 153(5), 1995, pp. 545-552
Objective: To describe women's attitudes and predicted behaviour regar
ding the potential for fetal tissue transplantation (FTT) to influence
abortion decisions. Design: Self-administered questionnaire survey by
mail. Setting: Academic family practice in Toronto. Participants: Ran
dom sample of 475 women 18 to 40 years of age selected from the family
practice registry of an urban teaching hospital. Family physicians we
re blind to their patients' participation, and investigators were blin
d to the subjects' identity. Forty questionnaires were undeliverable.
Of the remaining 435, 272 (62.5%) were completed. Six of the women wer
e over 40 years of age or did not indicate their age and were excluded
, which left 266 (61.1%) questionnaires for analysis. Outcome measures
: Number of women who would (a) be more likely to have an abortion if
they could donate tissue for FTT and (b) feel better or worse about ch
oosing abortion if FTT were an option, and open-ended comments about t
he potential for FTT to influence abortion decisions. Results: Of the
266 respondents 32 (12.0%) reported that they would be more likely to
have an abortion if they could donate tissue for FTT, 178 (66.9%) stat
ed that they would not be more likely to do so, and 56 (21.1%) were un
certain. Of the 122 who indicated that they would consider an abortion
if they were pregnant, 21 (17.2%) stated that they would be more like
ly to have an abortion if they could donate tissue for FTT, 77 (63.1%)
replied that they would not be more likely to do so, and 24 (19.7%) w
ere uncertain. The women 25 to 33 years of age were more likely to be
influenced by FTT than the younger or older women, and the women 18 to
24 years were more uncertain about the influence of FTT on abortion d
ecisions than the older women. In written responses some of the women
felt that FTT might make abortion decisions easier; many were troubled
that FTT might be used to justify a morally problematic abortion deci
sion and felt that FTT should not be used to justify abortion. Conclus
ion: The data, the first of their kind gathered from women, suggest th
at some women's abortion decisions may be influenced by the option to
donate tissue for FTT. Further research is necessary to explore the me
chanism of influence.