H. Pakker et al., A COMPARATIVE-STUDY OF TEMPERATURE RESPONSES OF CARIBBEAN SEAWEEDS FROM DIFFERENT BIOGEOGRAPHIC GROUPS, Journal of phycology, 31(4), 1995, pp. 499-507
Temperature tolerances were determined for Caribbean isolates (total 3
1) of seaweeds belonging to three distributional groups: 1) species co
nfined to the tropical western Atlantic (Botryocladia spinulifera, Cha
maedoris peniculum, Cladophoropsis sundanensis, Dictyopteris justii, D
ictyurus occidentalis, Haloplegma duperreyi, and Heterosiphonia gibbes
ii); 2) amphi-Atlantic species with a (sub)tropical distribution that
have their northern boundary in the eastern Atlantic at the tropical C
ape Verde Islands (Bryothamnion triquetrum and Ceramium nitens) or the
subtropical Canary Islands (Ceratodictyon intricatum, Coelothrix irre
gularis, Dictyopteris delicatula, Ernodesmis verticillata, and Lophocl
adia trichoclados; and 3 species with an amphi-Atlantic tropical to wa
rm-temperate distribution also occurring in the Mediterranean (Cladoph
oropsis membranacea, Digenea simplex, Microdictyon boergesenii, and Wu
rdemannia miniata). For some isolates, growth response curves and temp
erature requirements for reproduction were also determined. Growth occ
urred in the range (18)20 degrees-30 degrees C with optimum growth rat
es at 25 degrees-30 degrees C, irrespective of distribution group. Rep
roduction generally occurred at (20)25 degrees-30 degrees C although t
here were some exceptions. Species were extremely stenothermal, with t
hose restricted to the western Atlantic surviving a total range of onl
y 10 / 13 degrees C (between 18 / 20 degrees and 30 / 33 degrees C). T
olerance to high temperatures was correlated with vertical position in
the intertidal/subtidal zone rather than biogeographic grouping. Spec
ies restricted to the subtidal were the beast tolerant, with permanent
survival at 30 degrees C but not at 33 degrees C. Tolerance to low te
mperatures was not different in subtidal and intertidal species but wa
s significantly better in amphi-Atlantic than in western Atlantic spec
ies. In the former group, damage occurred at 15 degrees-18 degrees C b
ut in the latter group at 18 degrees-20 degrees C. We propose that the
se differences in low-temperature tolerances in Caribbean populations
of species from different distribution groups reflect adaptations to g
lacial cold-stress in the tropical eastern Atlantic and subsequent tra
ns-Atlantic dispersal.