Jm. Hopkinson et al., BODY-FAT ESTIMATION IN LATE PREGNANCY AND EARLY POSTPARTUM - COMPARISON OF 2-COMPONENT, 3-COMPONENT, AND 4-COMPONENT MODELS, The American journal of clinical nutrition, 65(2), 1997, pp. 432-438
Accurate methods for determining body fat mass during reproduction are
necessary to evaluate energy balance. However, determination of fat m
ass is complicated during pregnancy by the accretion of water, which i
nvalidates assumptions underlying standard two-compartment models. The
extent to which the variability in body water during pregnancy invali
dates use of pregnancy-corrected two-compartment models for determinat
ion of fat mass in individual women is unknown, Moreover, it is unclea
r whether body water returns to nonpregnant values by 2 wk postpartum,
which is frequently used as the baseline in studies of postpartum wom
en. The present study uses a four-component model as a criterion for e
valuating two- and three-component models. Fifty-six healthy, normoten
sive women between the ages of 19 and 35 y were studied at 36 +/- 1 wk
gestation and 15 +/- 2 d postpartum. Total body water (TBW), total bo
dy potassium (TBK), body density, and bone mineral content were measur
ed by deuterium dilution, whole-body potassium counting, hydrodensitom
etry, and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (postpartum only), respecti
vely. At 2 wk postpartum; hydration and density of fat-free mass (FFM)
had not returned to nonpregnant values, and differed between lactatin
g and nonlactating women (P < 0.05). Accordingly, standard TBW and bod
y density estimates of fat mass differed from four-component estimates
at both time points (P < 0.005). Moreover, our data indicate that eve
n when pregnancy-specific values for hydration or density of FFM are u
sed in TBW and body density models, individual fat mass estimates may
differ by > 3 kg from the Pour-component value. Fat mass by TBK may di
ffer by > 10 kg from fat mass by the four-component model during pregn
ancy. and by 6 kg postpartum. Use of standard two-compartment models t
o estimate fat mass results in significant error both during pregnancy
and at 2 wk postpartum. Pregnancy-corrected two-compartment models pr
oduce reliable mean fat mass estimates during pregnancy, but individua
l fat mass estimates may vary widely from four-component values.