Rh. Kraft et Ld. Nickel, SEX-RELATED DIFFERENCES IN COGNITION - DEVELOPMENT DURING EARLY-CHILDHOOD, Learning and individual differences, 7(3), 1995, pp. 249-271
Fifty-five right-handed children from right-handed families between 2-
and 5-years-of-age were individually administered two batteries of ha
nd preference, verbal and spatial measures with a six month interval s
eparating administrations. Early between-sex differences in production
and comprehension abilities were revealed; Girls outscored boys on me
asures of verbal fluency and graphic reproduction of shapes. Boys outs
cored girls on a measure of verbal comprehension. Within-sex differenc
es between comprehension and production abilities were also apparent.
At both administrations, boys scored significantly higher on verbal te
sts of knowledge, comprehension and reasoning than on measures requiri
ng oral or manual production. Girls showed the reverse pattern. By the
second administration, however, the high production/low comprehension
pattern was only significant for girls consistently demonstrating hig
h degrees of right-hand preference across testing times. Significant b
etween-sex differences in these comprehension versus production abilit
y patterns ranged between 1/2 to 11/6 standard deviations in magnitude
and accounted for 8-10% of the variance in children's ability differe
nce scores. These results are interpreted as support for a biological
basis of early sex-related cognitive differences and Kimura's (1983) m
odel of sex differences in the organization of the left hemisphere.