Nuclear and nucleomorph 18S ribosomal RNA genes from six cryptomonads
were amplified by the polymerase chain reaction and sequenced. Phyloge
netic trees were constructed by distance, parsimony, and maximum likel
ihood methods for all available cryptomonad nuclear and nucleomorph 18
S rRNA sequences. Nuclear and nucleomorph trees are largely congruent
and dearly disprove the idea of polyphyletic origins for cryptomonad c
hloroplasts. Both show the leucoplast-containing Chilomonas as the sis
ter to all photosynthetic cryptomonads. Using 11 cryptomonad nucleomor
ph sequences gives more convincing evidence than before that cryptomon
ad nucleomorphs originated from a red alga and are not specifically re
lated to Chlorarachnion nucleomorphs. Both trees show as a clade the g
enera with nucleomorphs embedded in a chloroplast-envelope invaginatio
n into the pyrenoid (Storeatula, Rhinomonas, Rhodomonas). This monophy
ly of embedded nucleomorphs supports the recent creation of the order
Pyrenomonadales for such cryptomonads. Cryptomonads ancestrally having
free nucleomorphs are much more diverse. Komma and Chroomonas, with t
he blue accessory pigment phycocyanin, form a clade, as do Guillardia
and Cryptomonas Phi, both with the red pigment phycoerythrin. The nucl
eomorph trees strongly show the blue Chroomonas/Komma dade as sister t
o all red-pigmented genera, but nuclear sequences support this weakly,
if at all, being sensitive to taxon sampling. Red and blue cryptomona
ds probably diverged early by differential pigment loss. Nuclear seque
nces provide no clear evidence for the nature of the host that engulfe
d the ancestral symbiont. Our nuclear trees using an extensive selecti
on of outgroups, and recent evidence from chloroplast DNA. are consist
ent with but do not positively support the view that the closest relat
ives of Cryptista (i.e. Cryptophyceae plus Goniomonadea) are the Chrom
obiota (i.e. Haptophyta plus Heterokonta, the latter including heterok
ont algae-phylum Ochrophyta), and that Cryptista and Chromobiota are a
ppropriately classified as subkingdoms of the kingdom Chromista. Maxim
um likelihood often groups Goniomonas with Chilomonas suggesting that
Goniomonas may have lost both nucleomorph and plastid and that the cry
ptist common ancestor was photosynthetic.