R. Chignola et al., HETEROGENEOUS RESPONSE OF INDIVIDUAL MULTICELLULAR TUMOR SPHEROIDS TOIMMUNOTOXINS AND RICIN TOXIN, British Journal of Cancer, 72(3), 1995, pp. 607-614
The cytoreductive effects of anti-transferrin receptor (anti-TfnR) imm
unotoxins (ITs) and of ricin toxin against tumour micromasses have bee
n evaluated in a multicellular tumour spheroid (MTS) model. More than
600 (656) MTSs obtained with human breast carcinoma (MCF7) or rat glio
blastoma (9L) cell lines were treated individually with ITs or toxin a
nd the effects induced by the treatment were measured for each MTS as
volume variation vs time by applying the Gompertz growth model. Two do
se-dependent patterns of MTS growth were observed in MTSs of both cell
lines in response to IT or toxin treatment: (1) complete inhibition o
f MTS growth ('sterilisation'); and (2) partial/complete inhibition ('
heterogeneous response'). Within the range of IT or toxin concentratio
ns resulting in partial inhibition of MTS growth, the sensitivity of t
reated MTSs was extremely heterogeneous (the cytoreductive effects var
ying between 0.1 and 4 logs of cells killed for a given IT or toxin co
ncentration). Analysis of the post-treatment regrowth kinetics indicat
ed that treated non-sterilised and control MTSs reached the same final
limiting volumes. However, the doubling time estimated for the surviv
ing cells of treated MCF7 and 9L MTSs ranged between 15 and 50 h, indi
cating that each MTS had individual growing potential. In conclusion,
our results indicate that at substerilising IT concentrations individu
al heterogeneity of MTSs may greatly influence the cytoreductive poten
tial of ITs. An implication of our study is that the efficacy of an IT
treatment in eradicating disseminated micrometastases may not be pred
ictable a priori. The MTS model that we describe in this paper may hel
p in dissecting out factors limiting the effect of ITs in three-dimens
ional tumours.