Rf. Madole et al., RIBBON CLIFF LANDSLIDE, WASHINGTON, AND THE EARTHQUAKE OF 14 DECEMBER1872, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 85(4), 1995, pp. 986-1002
Estimates of the epicentral location and maximum intensity of the eart
hquake of 14 December 1872, the largest and oldest historic earthquake
documented in the Pacific Northwest, are controversial largely becaus
e the estimates are based on ground effects. The Ribbon Cliff landslid
e is one of the more critical ground effects used to argue that the ep
icenter was in the vicinity of Lake Chelan in central Washington. Sket
chy historical accounts link the Ribbon Cliff landslide to the 1872 ea
rthquake, but a subsequent study disputed the historical accounts and,
on the basis of dendrochronology, concluded that the landslide occurr
ed more than 100 yr prior to the earthquake. However, Quaternary strat
igraphic relations and the results of multiple dating techniques repor
ted here indicate that the main Ribbon Cliff landslide probably occurr
ed within a 14-yr period that includes the time of the 1872 earthquake
. Although our study supports the historical accounts that link the la
ndslide to the December 1872 earthquake, it does not prove that seismi
c shaking triggered the landslide. Geomorphic and stratigraphic relati
ons show that Ribbon Cliff has a long and complex history and that the
landslide was not primarily a rockfall-rockslide that originated from
the cliff itself, as some believe, but rather that the main failure o
ccurred in colluvium that had accumulated beneath the cliff. Four coll
uvial units and two volcanic ash deposits, the Mazama ash bed (erupted
about 6.8 ka), and the Mount St. Helens set W (erupted about 1480 A.D
.), underlie the slopes below Ribbon Cliff. Most of the colluvium invo
lved in the landslide accumulated after deposition of the Mazama ash b
ed. Loss of support at the foot of the colluvial wedge because of unde
rcutting by the Columbia River probably was an important contributing
factor to slope failure.