This study investigated the relationship between epistemological world
views and identity formation. Forty college students, aged 17 to 23 y
ears, were presented with a paradigm belief scale (Social Paradigm Bel
ief Inventory; SPBI), an identity status questionnaire, and an in-dept
h interview about a conflict they had recently experienced. It was hyp
othesized that a relativistic world view would be related to a morator
ium identity status because relativistic thought processes involve a q
uestioning of the objectivity of knowledge and authority structures an
d hence an awareness of the variety of alternative and potentially con
flicting roles and choices. Results indicated that relativism was the
most common world view used when responding to questions about a perso
nal conflict and that relativistic scores on the SPBI were predictive
of the moratorium status. Relativistic scores on the SPBI were also ne
gatively related to identity achievement, as were mechanistic scores.
Females experienced moratorium to a greater extent than males but were
not more relativistic. Results are discussed in terms of linkages amo
ng cognitive development, psychosocial development, gender, and the ty
pe of measures used to assess world view status.