Dr. Young et al., INTERNAL VALIDITY OF THE PHYSICAL-ACTIVITY INDEX OVER 26 YEARS IN MIDDLE-AGED AND OLDER MEN, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 43(9), 1995, pp. 999-1006
OBJECTIVE: To determine the internal validity of the physical activity
index (PAI). DESIGN: Three time periods over a 26-year period (1965/6
8 examination, n = 7911; 1980/82 examination, n = 2054; 1991/93 examin
ation, n = 3425). SETTING: Honolulu, Hawaii. PARTICIPANTS: Middle-aged
to older Japanese-American men. MEASUREMENTS: PAI, other physical act
ivity measures, body mass index (BMI), tricep skinfold thickness, subs
capular skinfold thickness, and HDL cholesterol. RESULTS: PAI level wa
s associated significantly with levels of other physical activity meas
ures at all time periods. Higher PAI level was associated with lower B
MI at the baseline examination (1965/68), lower subscapular skinfold t
hickness at the 1965/68 and 1980/82 examinations, lower tricep skinfol
d thickness at all examinations, and higher HDL cholesterol at the 198
0/82 examination. Change in PAI level from 1965/68 to 1980/82 was asso
ciated with change in BMI, subscapular, and tricep skinfold thickness
levels, but there were no significant associations between change in P
AI level and change in BMI, skinfold thicknesses, or HDL cholesterol l
evels from 1980/82 to 1991/93. CONCLUSION: PAI level is a relatively v
alid estimate of overall daily energy expenditure that may be an accep
table general measure across the middle-to-late stages of life. The PA
I may also be sensitive enough to discern a shift toward less physical
demanding activities as a population becomes older, although further
studies should be conducted to better determine its validity in older
populations.