RATIONAL CHOICE AND THE ROLE OF THEORY IN POLITICAL-SCIENCE

In their survey of empirical research based on rational choice theory, Don Green and Ian Shapiro point to a list of methodological deficienc ies or ''pathologies.'' The main problem with Green and Shapiro's list lies in the standards they use to evaluate the achievements of ration al choice theory. These standards are derived from a view of empirical research that is deeply questionable and, in the stated form, inconsi stent with both standard insights in contemporary philosophy of scienc e and the established practice in the most successful empirical scienc es.