Ka. Hughes et al., EXPLORATION AND EXPLOITATION OF SOIL BY APPLE, KIWIFRUIT, PEACH, ASIAN PEAR AND GRAPE ROOTS, Plant and soil, 175(2), 1995, pp. 301-309
Measurements of root-length density (RLD) in a range of 31 apple, kiwi
fruit, peach, Asian pear and grape orchards were used to derive indice
s to describe the exploration and exploitation of rooting volumes. Orc
hards were of various ages and located on a range of soil types, geogr
aphic regions, management systems etc. Data were obtained from core sa
mples of volume 1.66 x 10(-4) m(3) randomly taken within a ''standard
volume'', determined by average planting grids, of 2 m radius centred
on tree stems, and 1 m depth. Root systems were described using an exp
loitation index, E(phi), and an exploration index, E(0). E(phi) is def
ined as the proportion of the soil volume which contains roots at RLD
greater than or equal to some specified value, phi. E(0) is defined as
the proportion of the soil volume which contains roots at any RLD gre
ater than zero. These indices are dependent on sample size, as are all
volumetric or soil-coring data. Estimates of E(0) for each orchard we
re obtained as the proportions of cores containing any RLD>O and asses
sed for dependence on species. Peach trees had a significantly higher
value of E(0), equal to almost 1.0, compared to the other four species
where E(0) was approximately 0.8 (p less than or equal to 0.01) or le
ss. There was also some variation with age. E(0) was lower for very yo
ung plants which had not fully occupied the sampled soil volume. Explo
ration indices for woody roots increased with rootstock age but otherw
ise did not explain large differences in E(phi) between species for gi
ven phi values. For example at phi = 0.05 x 10(4) m.m(-3), E(phi) was
approximately 0.45 for peach and kiwifruit, and 0.05 for apple, Asian
pear and grape, whereas at phi = 0.5 x 10(4) m.m(-3) the corresponding
values were 0.1 and almost zero. Negative exponential curves relating
E(phi), scaled by dividing by E(0), to phi were fitted for each of th
e 31 orchards. Exponents for these curves, k, were significantly small
er for kiwifruit and peaches than apples, grapes and Asian pears (p le
ss than or equal to 0.05), and smaller for apples than grapes and Asia
n pears (p less than or equal to 0.05). A larger k implies a rapid fal
l-off in E(phi) as phi increases. Although all five species contained
zero and low RLD samples, only kiwifruit and peaches contained higher
RLD values and consequently have higher mean RLD. This trend was consi
stent across all soils, regions, sampling dates, and plant ages. The a
nalyses demonstrate that core sampling can give useful insights into m
acro-scale root-system distribution, such as the proportion of a soil
volume explored and how it is exploited. If positions of core samples
are noted during sampling using angular direction, depth and radial di
stance as spatial coordinates the method can be used to describe root-
system structures.