Humans are important geological agents over recent and historic time s
cales, but whether human agency is significant in the context of longe
r-term geologic evolution is unresolved, Are anthropic impacts ''noise
'' in the grand trend of Earth's evolution or a fundamental change in
the geologic environment? Four approaches to this problem are outlined
, based on principles for determining whether or under what circumstan
ces geologic processes or phenomena should be considered interdependen
t or independent. The approaches are illustrated with field problems c
oncerned with Holocene Impacts of human agency on geomorphic processes
in the coastal plain of North Carolina. Whether humans represent shor
t-term perturbations or more fundamental long-term changes in geologic
systems depends on the problem, geologic system, and time scale of in
terest; on the durations and frequencies of human impacts; on the sens
itivity and relaxation times of the geologic components; and on the re
lative rates of the human-influenced and relevant non-human geologic p
rocesses, These principles can be incorporated into quantitative tools
to address scale issues with respect to human agency in specific geol
ogic systems.