Grazer-periphyton interactions were investigated in 11 laboratory stre
ams holding a range of densities of three herbivore taxa during a 32-d
experiment. Effects of grazers on algae were strongest with Dicosmoec
us gilvipes caddisflies, intermediate with Juga silicula snails, and w
eakest with Baetis spp. mayflies. Algal standing crop, export, and gro
ss primary production declined logarithmically with increasing grazer
density. Algal turnover rate, however, increased with grazer abundance
. At high densities of all grazers, responses in most algal parameters
converged, suggesting that high grazing pressure, regardless of taxon
, will similarly affect periphyton. Growth of both Dicosmoecus caddisf
lies and Juga snails was density-dependent, with the highest growth ra
tes occurring at the lowest densities. Caddisflies displayed high grow
th rates but low efficiency in resource use. Snails had lower growth r
ates but were more efficient in resource use. The coexistence of Dicos
moecus and Juga, or other competing herbivores, in natural streams may
be related to these fundamental differences in life history strategie
s.