Jaw. Kirsch et al., PHYLOGENY OF THE PTEROPODIDAE (MAMMALIA, CHIROPTERA) BASED ON DNA HYBRIDIZATION, WITH EVIDENCE FOR BAT MONOPHYLY, Australian journal of zoology, 43(4), 1995, pp. 395-428
We constructed DNA-hybridisation matrices comparing 18 genera of Megac
hiroptera and an outgroup microchiropteran, and eight species of Ptero
pus and two related genera. Three species each of Megachiroptera and M
icrochiroptera, two of Primates, and an outgroup armadillo were compar
ed in another matrix; additional representatives of other mammalian or
ders figured in a further set of experiments. Among the megachiroptera
ns examined, Nyctimene and Paranyctimene comprise the sister-group to
other pteropodids. Of the 'macroglossines', only Macroglossus and Syco
nycteris are associated apart from typical pteropodines, while the fou
r remaining nectar-feeders (Eonycteris, Megaloglossus, Melonycteris, N
otopteris) are independently linked with non-nectar-feeding clades. Th
us, Megaloglossus is the nearest relative of Lissonycteris, with Epomo
phorus and Rousettus successive sister-groups to both, while Eonycteri
s is the sister of all four; Melonycteris and Pteralopex form a tricho
tomy with the closely related Acerodon and Pteropus, and Notopteris is
the sister-taxon to all four. It therefore appears that anatomical sp
ecialisations for nectar- and pollen-feeding evolved (or were lost) se
veral times within Pteropodidae. Cynopterus and Dobsonia represent add
itional clades within the Pteropodinae, with which Thoopterus and Apro
teles are respectively paired. Comparisons among species of Pteropus a
nd related genera suggest that Acerodon may be congeneric with Pteropu
s, but that Pteralopex clearly is not. The ordinal-level matrices supp
ort bat monophyly: no order tested is closer to either of the chiropte
ran suborders than they are to each other, and bats are separated from
Primates by at least two nodes. On the basis of previous rate determi
nations for mammals, we estimate that the African grouping (Epomophoru
s, Megaloglossus, Lissonycteris) is mid-Miocene in origin, that the tw
o major pteropodid subfamilies (Nyctimeninae and Pteropodinae, includi
ng 'Macroglossinae') separated in the Early Miocene, and that the dive
rgence of chiropteran suborders dates from the latest Cretaceous or ea
rliest Palaeocene. Arrangement of genera within Pteropodidae supports
the family's Australo-Pacific or south-east Asian origin.