Self-organization is common in earth surface systems, and related prin
ciples have been proposed as general principles applicable to geomorph
ic systems. Non-self-organizing behaviour is also observed in geomorph
ic systems, however. If a reasonable box-and-arrow diagram and associa
ted qualitative interaction matrix can be devised for a geomorphic sys
tem, one can determine whether or not (or under what conditions) the s
ystem is self-organizing, Both self-organizing (at-a-station hydraulic
geometry) and non-self-organizing (soil landscape evolution) geomorph
ic systems are illustrated. The development of topographic relief demo
nstrates the principle that landscape evolution may be characterized b
y both modes at different times or under different circumstances. Incr
easing relief, involving a mean divergence of elevations, may be self-
organizing. Topographic development by decreasing relief, where elevat
ions generally converge, is always non-self-organizing Self-organizati
on in geomorphology may be similar to steady-state equilibrium, in tha
t its explanatory value lies not in general applicability, but in dist
inguishing between fundamentally different modes of landscape developm
ent.