F. Gerr et al., SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY OF VIBROMETRY FOR DETECTION OF CARPAL-TUNNEL SYNDROME, Journal of occupational and environmental medicine, 37(9), 1995, pp. 1108-1115
A cross-sectional study was performed to assess the utility of vibrota
ctile thresholds (VTs) obtained before and after a 10-minute period of
wrist flexion as a method for detection of carpal tunnel syndrome (CT
S) among adult subjects. Subjects with hand discomfort were recruited
from patients referred to a university-based electromyography laborato
ry. Asymtomatic subjects were recruited from among office and technica
l staff at a professional school. In addition, to electrophysiologic e
valuation (EP), all subjects were offered VT measurement of the index
and small fingers, bilaterally, before and after a 10-minute; period o
f wrist flexion. A total of 144 subjects were recruited and three hand
-condition groups were established: 57 hands had symptoms and EP resul
ts compatible with CTS (Group 1), 58 hands had symptoms compatible wit
h CTS and normal EP results (Group 2), and 123 hands had no symptoms a
nd normal EP results (Group 3). Group 1 was considered the ''disease-p
ositive'' group, and Groups 2 and 3 were both considered ''disease-neg
ative'' groups. Analyses were performed separately for dominant and no
ndominant hands, and results were pooled when appropriate. Outcomes of
interest were the VTs obtained from the index and small fingers befor
e and after 10 minutes of maximal voluntary wrist flexion as well as v
ariables calculated from them. Significant differences in mean VT were
observed between the three hand-condition groups for most of the outc
omes evaluated. At any given level of specificity, the sensitivity of
vibrometry performed after 10 minutes of wrist flexion was approximate
ly two times that obtained before wrist flexion for detection of elect
rophysiologically confirmed CTS. At specificities of 70 and 80%, the b
est sensitivity observed among vibrometry outcomes obtained after wris
t flexion were 61 and 57%, whereas the best sensitivities observed amo
ng vibrometry outcomes obtained before wrist flexion were 35 and 28%.