To determine the strength, frequency, and nature of density-dependent
processes in natural plant populations, the densities of two perennial
grass species, Bouteloua rigidiseta and Aristida longiseta, were pert
urbed in an otherwise undisturbed community. Both seed additions and a
dult removals, of each species separately, were used. Individual plant
survival, growth, and reproduction were monitored, as well as recruit
ment to the population and the numbers in each size class of each spec
ies, for 5 yr. The responses to the experimental perturbations were sm
all relative to the magnitude of the perturbations, indicating that de
nsity dependence in demographic parameters in both populations was wea
k throughout the period. The results therefore do not support the sugg
estion of Fowler (1986) that the weak density dependence in the Boutel
oua rigidiseta population in the ist yr of the experiment was a tempor
ary result of drought. Significant responses to the density manipulati
ons were scattered among annual intervals, characters, and replicates.
This may be simply a result of testing responses at the limits of det
ectability, or it may reflect intermittent and scattered density depen
dence. Density effects were generally much smaller than other differen
ces among quadrats and differences among plants within quadrats, indic
ating that other factors had much more effect on a plant's fate.