Mh. Miller et al., FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY OF VESICULAR-ARBUSCULAR MYCORRHIZAS AS INFLUENCED BY PHOSPHATE FERTILIZATION AND TILLAGE IN AN AGRICULTURAL ECOSYSTEM, Critical reviews in biotechnology, 15(3-4), 1995, pp. 241-255
The importance of vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizas (VAM) in an agricul
tural crop production system depends largely on our ability, through s
oil management, to increase the effectiveness of the indigenous mycorr
hizal fungal population. To do so requires a good understanding of the
functional ecology of the symbiosis. In this article, we discuss prim
arily our programs at Guelph, which have focused on two aspects of the
symbiosis: the influence of phosphate (P) fertilization on colonizati
on and the influence of soil disturbance by tillage on colonization an
d P absorption. Although it is generally accepted that the level of co
lonization of roots by VAM fungi decreases with increased P availabili
ty, we have found that the decrease is not as marked as thought. A rea
sonable degree of colonization was observed at available P levels well
above those required for maximum yield. We have also found that the r
eduction in colonization occurs to a greater extent in the roots growi
ng in a fertilized zone than in those outside this zone. Thus, althoug
h a band application of fertilizer may markedly reduce colonization in
the fertilized zone, the remainder of the root system would be well c
olonized, and have an increased ability to acquire phosphorus. That so
il disturbance by tillage reduces the effectiveness of the VAM symbios
is in maize was first observed in the early 1980s. Since then we have
conducted numerous field and growth chamber experiments to determine t
he practical importance of this effect in crop production and to eluci
date the mechanisms involved. Systems such as no-till and ridge-till h
ave been shown to result in greater P absorption during early maize gr
owth. They also result in earlier colonization in some, but not all, c
ases. We have not, as yet, observed a yield advantage as a result of t
he earlier P absorption. This may be because factors other than P nutr
ition are limiting yields with the reduced tillage systems. Our result
s do indicate quite clearly, however, that greater rates of P fertiliz
er are not required in reduced tillage systems, compared with systems
that cause a greater degree of soil disturbance. We suggest that lesse
r rates of P fertilizer may be required, which would have both an econ
omic and environmental impact. Our studies to elucidate the mechanisms
have led to the conclusion that the integrity of the extraradical myc
elium from a previous crop is a critical factor in the greater early P
absorption in undisturbed systems. It may also be important in rapid
colonization of roots of newly developing seedlings. This latter effec
t, however, has been quite inconsistent in our studies. It is apparent
that some unknown factor or factors, in addition to the integrity of
the mycelium, is also critical. The fact that a preexisting extraradic
al mycelium is important for early P nutrition under our field conditi
ons led to the hypothesis that the mycelium from a previous crop retai
ns its infectivity and is able to absorb and transport P to newly atta
ched roots following an extensive period during which the soil is froz
en. Experiments in which pouches containing soil with a root-free myce
lium were exposed to freezing for differing lengths of time have provi
ded evidence to support this hypothesis. Roots growing in undisturbed
pouches removed from the field when the soil was frozen were rapidly c
olonized during a bioassay. Disturbance of the soil in these pouches i
nvariably reduced P absorption by the bioassay plants and sometimes, b
ut not always, reduced colonization. A more thorough understanding of
the mechanisms involved in the effect of disturbance on colonization w
ould increase the potential for increasing the effectiveness of the VA
M symbiosis in crop production through management practices.