Some doubts have expressed in the recent literature about the occurren
ce of earthquake that occurred simultaneously with a cyclonic storm du
ring September/October 1737 near Calcutta. In this article an attempt
has been made to probe into the historical documents with a logical an
alysis. Our study reveals that an earthquake did occur undoubtedly nea
r Calcutta in 1737. However, the death toll reported in the catalogue
of significant earthquakes by the US Department of Commerce needs to b
e corrected. It was also found that the Encyclopedia Brittanica has mi
ssed to make entry of the earthquake, in addition to making inadverten
tly a wrong entry of the date of occurence of the cyclonic storm. This
study has led to the conclusion that an earthquake did occur near Cal
cutta during the passage of a sever e cyclonic storm on the Bengal coa
st of the night of 11 October 1737 as per the Gregorian equivalent cal
endar, or on 30 September 1737 as per the then existing Julian calenda
r. The death toll due to the combined disaster could have been about 3
000.