Two mutant RNAs, one derived from tRNA(i)(met), the second from U1 snR
NA, that are defective in export from the nucleus to the cytoplasm hav
e been studied. In both cases, the RNAs are shown to be transport comp
etent but prevented from leaving the nucleus by interaction with satur
able binding sites. This contradicts previous hypotheses to explain th
e behavior of the tRNA mutant, and highlights a general problem in usi
ng mutant RNAs to study nuclear export. In the case of these mutants,
it is argued that nuclear retention is likely to be artifactual. Howev
er, the additional example of U6 snRNA is described. In this case, nuc
lear retention appears to be a physiological mechanism by which intran
uclear localization is achieved. Evidence that the site of interaction
with the La protein in U6 snRNA is important for its nuclear retentio
n is presented.