M. Nichter et al., DIETING AND WATCHING BEHAVIORS AMONG ADOLESCENT FEMALES - REPORT OF AMULTIMETHOD STUDY, Journal of adolescent health, 17(3), 1995, pp. 153-162
Purpose: This study posits a distinction between ''watching what you e
at'' and dieting behaviors in a sample of adolescent females. Findings
suggest that the dichotomy of dieter/nondieter fails to capture a ran
ge of healthful behaviors practiced by many adolescent girls. Methods:
Anthropologic and nutritional research methods were used in this stud
y. Data were drawn from 1 year of a longitudinal study of food intake
and dieting behaviors in a sample of 231 adolescent females. Multiple
methods including one ethnographic interview, a survey questionnaire,
a telephone interview, and food records were collected from each infor
mant. Results: Although 44% of the girls in this sample reported tryin
g to lose weight on the day of the survey, only 8.6% of the food recor
ds reflected dieting days. In interviews, many identified ''watching w
hat they eat'' as a health-promoting strategy that allowed them to mai
ntain their weight. Analysis of food record data confirmed a trend tow
ard higher intakes of micronutrients. Conclusions: Research concerned
with adolescent weight loss behaviors has focused more on negative tha
n positive health attitudes and behaviors. The present study identifie
d the behavior of ''watching'' as distinct from dieting. ''Watching''
was widely utilized by girls in this sample as a way to maintain weigh
t and promote health.