P. Nazzaro et al., ANTIHYPERTENSIVE TREATMENT WITH VERAPAMIL AND AMLODIPINE - THEIR EFFECT ON THE FUNCTIONAL AUTONOMIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR STRESS RESPONSES, European heart journal, 16(9), 1995, pp. 1277-1284
Many biological and psycho logical factors induced haemodynamic and ex
tra-cardiovascular functional changes mediated by the autonomic nervou
s system. Pharmacological blood pressure reduction, as a neurovegetati
ve stimulus, can change the arousal of the sympathetic nervous system.
We evaluated the effects of two calcium channel blockers, verapamil a
nd amlodipine, both administered as monotherapies, upon the sympatheti
c stress response in 23 randomized mild-to-moderate essential hyperten
sives (161 +/- 2/98 +/- I mmHg). Patients performed for stress tests (
mental arithmetic, colour word Stroop, cold presser and handgrip) whil
e extracardiovascular and haemodynamic functions were assessed non-inv
asively at every heart brat, during baseline, stress and recovery phas
es. The sympathetic response was evaluated by computing the 'area-unde
r-the-curve' (value x time) measured during the psychophysiological se
ssion. The session was repeated at run-in, after placebo and during tr
eatment. After one month's treatment, baseline blood pressure was sign
ificantly reduced in patients treated with amlodipine (139 +/- 1/84 +/
- 1 mmHg; P<0.001) and verapamil (140 +/- 2/85 +/- I mmHg, P<0.001). T
he emotional arousal (frontalis muscular contraction skirt conductance
) was unchanged bur the cutaneous vascular response was reduced (P<0.0
5) in patients treated with verapamil. No changes in systolic or diast
olic blood pressure were detectable, but amlodipine increased the hear
t rate response (P<0.05). In contrast, verapamil reduced the heart rat
e (P<0.05) without depressing the cardiac output response, which was i
ncreased with amlodipine (P<0.05). Total vascular resistance was signi
ficantly (P<0.001) reduced with both the treatments. Consequently func
tional cardiac load, expressed by pressure-rate product and cardiac po
wer, was significantly enhanced with amlodipine and reduced with verap
amil. In conclusion, the abnormal sympathetic stress response, which c
haracterizes the hypertensive patient, might be affected by the choice
of medication. Verapamil in particular, moderated emotional arousal,
the vasoconstrictive response and reduced cardiac load without lowerin
g cardiac output demands. In contrast, in patients treated with amlodi
pine, in whom the cardiac output response was increased the pattern wa
s reversed and the functional cardiac load was also increased.