Objective: To analyze efficiency and reliability of 4 modern neonatal
ventilators;under difficult test conditions. The ventilators tested we
re: Babylog 8000 (Drager Medical), BP 2001 (Bear Medical Systems), Sec
hrist IV 100 B (Sechrist Industries), Infant Star (Infrasonics INC). M
easurements and results: Gas flow generation was tested by comparison
of preset flow values with no resistance in the circuit to flow values
obtained during interposition of a resistance in the inspiratory circ
uit. A decrease in gas flow was observed when interposition of a resis
tance in the inspiratory circuit increased peak inspiratory pressure t
o 60 cmH(2)O (gas flow decreased by 8% to 24% depending on the ventila
tor tested). The pressure limiting valve and the positive end-expirato
ry pressure valve were also evaluated in order to test their behaviour
under different flow conditions. Flow-dependence of the pressure was
noted for all ventilators except Babylog 8000. Assessment of the relia
bility of pressure monitoring revealed either 'under' or 'over' estima
tion of peak inspiratory pressure and positive end-expiratory pressure
depending on the ventilator tested. Conclusion: For the best clinical
use of mechanical ventilators, neonatologists should be aware of thes
e limitations. Therefore a regular assessment of ventilator performanc
e and monitoring reliability is recommended.