In years of low planktivory by fish, midsummer declines and low popula
tion abundances of Daphnia pulicaria in Lake Mendota, WI, USA have bee
n attributed to poor food quality and low food abundance. This hypothe
sis has been proposed because of midsummer blooms of blue-green algae
in this eutrophic urban lake. We tested the hypothesis by performing i
n situ food manipulations during the midsummer decline of the D. pulic
aria population, and during the early autumn low population period. In
July, animals held in clear plastic vials containing GF/F filtered la
ke water exhibited poor survivorship, ceased producing offspring after
three days, and had low lipid reserves. Daphnids fed whole-lake water
or filtered water enriched with Chlamydomonas survived at a significa
ntly higher rate and produced abundant offspring. In September, there
were no significant differences in survivorship among treatments, but
animals fed water enriched with Chlamydomonas produced significantly m
ore offspring than animals in the other treatments. The hypothesis of
poor food quality causing the midsummer decline of the Daphnia populat
ion is not supported by our experiments. Because predation by juvenile
fish does not appear to be important in regulating the midsummer Daph
nia population during these years, alternate hypotheses for the midsum
mer decline are suggested. These include increased predation by invert
ebrate predators such as Leptodora kindtii, a life history shift by da
phnids during midsummer to production of resting eggs, and a combinati
on of low levels of planktivory and deteriorating feeding conditions a
cting together to cause the population decline.