Jm. Tielsch et al., PREOPERATIVE FUNCTIONAL EXPECTATIONS AND POSTOPERATIVE OUTCOMES AMONGPATIENTS UNDERGOING FIRST EYE CATARACT-SURGERY, Archives of ophthalmology, 113(10), 1995, pp. 1312-1318
Objective: To describe the relationship between patients' preoperative
expectations regarding the outcome of cataract surgery and actual pos
toperative experience. Methods: A longitudinal study of 772 patients u
ndergoing first eye cataract surgery recruited from 75 ophthalmology p
ractices in three metropolitan areas was conducted. Prior to surgery a
nd approximately 4 months after surgery, a detailed interview was cond
ucted that included general and vision-specific health status measures
(including the Visual Function 12-Item Scale [VF-12]), patient-report
ed level of trouble and satisfaction with vision, and questions addres
sing patients' preoperative expectations regarding the outcomes of sur
gery. In addition, detailed clinical data were collected preoperativel
y and postoperatively. A total of 552 patients had only single eye cat
aract surgery by 4 months postoperatively and are included in this ana
lysis. Results: Patients' preoperative expectations regarding the impa
ct of cataract surgery were very high and were unrelated to their demo
graphic or ocular characteristics. The preoperative VF-12 score, howev
er, was positively correlated with expected postoperative VF-12 score
(Spearman correlation, .45, P<.001). Only 61% of patients achieved or
surpassed their expected level of postoperative functioning. The diffe
rence between expected and actual postoperative VF-12 scores was not a
ssociated with patients' demographic characteristics or provider-relat
ed variables. Older patients (>75 years) and patients with ocular como
rbidity had a larger difference between expected and actual postoperat
ive functioning than younger patients and those without ocular comorbi
dity. Conclusion: Expectations regarding visual functioning after cata
ract surgery are very high, and in most cases such expectations are fu
lfilled. In selected cases, more comprehensive counseling may reduce t
he discrepancy between expectations and actual outcomes of cataract su
rgery.