Hotani, has studied, by means of dark-field light microscopy,morpholog
ical transformations which unilamellar liposomes undergo when their in
terior volume decreases steadily with time as a consequence of osmosis
. In a previous paper, we made a theoretical study of the initial buck
ling of an originally spherical vesicle into the observed oblate spher
oidal shape; and we argued that some in-plane shear elastic stiffness
is required - in addition to the well-known flexural stiffness of the
lipid bilayer - in order to explain the observed phenomena. In the pre
sent paper, we consider a later stage in the chain of morphological tr
ansitions observed by Hotani, when a series of cudgel-shaped lobes hav
e sprung out of a previously axisymmetric, biconcave-shaped vesicle. S
pecifically, we compare the observed shapes of such lobes with half of
a series of ''peanut''-shaped vesicles that are an equilibrium confor
mation of an initially spherical liposome under reduced internal volum
e. We find that the shapes do not match well. On the other hand, the o
bserved lobe forms do match satisfactorily portions of ''undulating tu
be'' shapes which evolve from a hypothetical cylindrical vesicle, acco
rding to some simple calculations. In view of this agreement, we are l
ed to propose that the formation of cudgel-shaped lobes requires some
sliding of one lipid monolayer over another. This conflicts, of course
, with the Love-Kirchhoff hypothesis which is normally invoked at the
outset of analyses of lipid vesicles by means of classical thin-shell
theory; but it is in accord with previous suggestions in the context o
f more obviously severe distortion of the lipid bilayer.