STRATEGY THAT INCLUDES SERIAL NONINVASIVE LEG TESTS FOR DIAGNOSIS OF THROMBOEMBOLIC DISEASE IN PATIENTS WITH SUSPECTED ACUTE PULMONARY-EMBOLISM BASED ON DATA FROM PIOPED
Pd. Stein et al., STRATEGY THAT INCLUDES SERIAL NONINVASIVE LEG TESTS FOR DIAGNOSIS OF THROMBOEMBOLIC DISEASE IN PATIENTS WITH SUSPECTED ACUTE PULMONARY-EMBOLISM BASED ON DATA FROM PIOPED, Archives of internal medicine, 155(19), 1995, pp. 2101-2104
Objective: To estimate the percentage of patients with suspected acute
pulmonary embolism in whom a noninvasive diagnosis or exclusion of th
romboembolic disease might be safely made on the basis of ventilation-
perfusion (VQ) lung scans, single noninvasive tests of the lower extre
mities, and, in patients with adequate cardiorespiratory reserve, seri
al noninvasive tests of the lower extremities. Methods: Calculations w
ere made among 662 patients who participated in the collaborative stud
y Prospective Investigation of Pulmonary Embolism Diagnosis (PIOPED) a
nd who had blood gas values measured while breathing room air and who
underwent pulmonary angiography. The diagnostic strategy recommends tr
eatment in all patients with a high-probability VQ scan and no treatme
nt in patients with nearly normal VQ scans. Inpatients with nondiagnos
tic VQ scans (intermediate- or low-probability scans), a single noninv
asive leg testis recommended. It was assumed that 50% of patients with
pulmonary embolism would show deep venous thrombosis with a single no
ninvasive leg test. If results are abnormal, treatment is indicated. I
f normal, serial noninvasive leg tests are recommended. Treatment can
be withheld if results of serial tests are normal. In patients with po
or cardiorespiratory reserve, pulmonary angiography is indicated. Resu
lts: A single noninvasive leg test in patients with nondiagnostic VQ s
cans would show deep venous thrombosis and, therefore, eliminate the n
eed for pulmonary angiography in 53 (11%) of 468 patients (95% confide
nce interval [CI], 9% to 15%) who otherwise would require angiography.
Serial noninvasive leg tests in patients with adequate cardiorespirat
ory reserve who had a normal result of a single leg test would either
show deep venous thrombosis or exclude it in 222 (47%) of 468 patients
(95% CI, 43% to 52%). The need for pulmonary angiography, therefore,
would be reduced from 468 (71%) of 662 (95% CI, 67% to 74%) if no noni
nvasive leg tests were performed to 415 (63%) of 662 (95% CI, 59% to 6
6%) if only a single noninvasive leg test were performed, and further
reduced to 193 (29%) of 662 (95% CI, 26% to 33%) if serial noninvasive
leg tests were used where appropriate. Conclusion: A noninvasive stra
tegy that includes VQ scans, single noninvasive leg tests, and serial
noninvasive leg tests would permit a diagnosis of thromboembolic disea
se or a safe exclusion of thromboembolic disease in 71% of patients wi
th suspected acute pulmonary embolism.