A COMPARISON OF FLUOROSCOPY AND COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY-DERIVED VOLUMETRIC MULTIPLE EXPOSURE TRANSMISSION HOLOGRAPHY FOR THE GUIDANCE OF LUMBARPEDICLE SCREW INSERTION
Ec. Benzel et al., A COMPARISON OF FLUOROSCOPY AND COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY-DERIVED VOLUMETRIC MULTIPLE EXPOSURE TRANSMISSION HOLOGRAPHY FOR THE GUIDANCE OF LUMBARPEDICLE SCREW INSERTION, Neurosurgery, 37(4), 1995, pp. 711-716
HOLOGRAPHIC TECHNOLOGY HAS recently been modified in such a manner tha
t it may now provide clinical use. It allows the visualization of comp
lex structures in three dimensions and permits clinician interaction w
ith the image, which, in turn, provides significant additional geometr
ic and anatomic information. To objectively assess the potential clini
cal applicability of holography in pedicle screw placement, we studied
11 elderly human cadavers. All of the cadavers, each of which showed
significant degenerative disease of the lumbar spine, underwent thin-s
ection computed tomographic scans of the lumbar spine. The acquired di
gital information was processed, and volumetric multiple exposure tran
smission holographic images were rendered. Pedicle screws were passed
into anatomically acceptable and radiographically visualized L3-L5 ped
icles in each cadaver, half using fluoroscopic guidance and half using
holographic guidance alone. The accuracy of screw placement was objec
tively assessed by a three-point grading scale. The total score for th
e placement of each pedicle screw was determined by both trajectory (l
ocation within the pedicle) and accuracy (containment within the verte
bral body) of screw tip placement parameters. Three points were possib
le for each screw placed. Screw placement in the last six cadavers was
individually timed for each technique, and fluoroscopic time was also
recorded. Each technique was used on 27 pedicles. The total score for
fluoroscopic screw placement was 71 (71 of a possible 81; 88%) and fo
r holographic screw placement was 74 (74 of a possible 81; 91%). In th
e last six cadavers, the screw placement time (per cadaver) was 8 minu
tes for fluoroscopic placement and 3.6 minutes for holographic placeme
nt. Fluoroscopic time averaged 1.9 minutes per cadaver. The close appr
oximation of the accuracy of holographic guidance with that of fluoros
copic guidance, combined with its speed and safety, indicates that vol
umetric multiple exposure transmission holography may facilitate pedic
le screw placement.