E. Nagy et al., JAPANESE OFFICE EMPLOYEES PSYCHOLOGICAL REACTIONS TO THEIR UNDERGROUND AND ABOVEGROUND OFFICES, Journal of environmental psychology, 15(2), 1995, pp. 123-134
The discussion about underground spaces for office use has intensified
during the past few decades, but the human reactions towards them are
not yet well understood. Furthermore, most of the previous studies ha
ve been carried out in western countries. In the present study, Japane
se office workers' psychological reactions to underground and above-gr
ound offices were investigated with regard to the perceived importance
of windows in the office, and the perceived lighting and visual condi
tions in the underground and above-ground offices. The study was carri
ed out in the form of a questionnaire survey. The subjects were 22 emp
loyees in underground and 86 employees in above-ground offices. The re
sults confirmed that windows were strongly desired in offices, especia
lly by employees working underground and not having windows. The under
ground employees also evaluated their lighting condition more negative
ly than did the above-ground workers. Considering that type of furnitu
re and colour scheme, as well as other environmental factors, such as
type and level of artificial lighting, temperature and noise level, we
re very similar in the underground and above-ground offices, it is con
cluded that the perceived need for windows and the perception of the l
ighting conditions in our study was strongly influenced by psychologic
al factors, such as the awareness of being underground. Furthermore, t
he Japanese subjects' reactions were similar to those of the western s
ubjects found in previous studies, which suggests that reactions towar
ds windowlessness and underground spaces are widespread, not influence
d substantially by cultural or climatic conditions. It is, therefore,
argued that underground spaces for office use should be avoided as muc
h as possible. If underground space utilization is necessary, the occu
pants' psychological reactions should be considered to a much greater
extent in the design process than is the case at present.