Rw. Gibbs et al., INFERRING MEANINGS THAT ARE NOT INTENDED - SPEAKERS INTENTIONS AND IRONY COMPREHENSION, Discourse processes, 20(2), 1995, pp. 187-203
Most cases of verbal irony involve a situation in which a speaker says
one thing and deliberately intends for his or her listener to infer a
n ironic meaning (e.g., ''What lovely weather!'' spoken in the midst o
f a downpour). However, there are occasions when listeners infer ironi
c meanings for utterances even though speakers do not intend their utt
erances to convey irony. For example, listeners may infer that the exp
ression ''I would never be involved in any cheating'' may have an iron
ic meaning if the speaker, unbeknownst to him or her, actually contrib
uted to someone's cheating in a class exam. Numerous instances of dram
atic irony in literature are based on situations like this in which li
steners or readers recognize the unintended irony in what speakers say
. We report the results of four experiments to show that people can re
cognize ironic meanings that are not intended by speakers and that pro
cessing unintended irony can be done quite easily precisely because sp
eakers' utterances, unbeknownst to them, spontaneously create ironic s
ituations. These findings have significant implications for psycholing
uistic theories of irony comprehension and, more generally, for intent
ional theories of ordinary language use.