In the recent theoretical proposal of S. T. A. Pickett and colleagues,
a patch dynamic concept of secondary succession is used to develop ge
neral laws of vegetational change. While this proposal is an important
step in the formalization of vegetation theory, its basis in secondar
y succession limits its applicability at larger spatial or temporal sc
ales than those of single disturbance patches. We show that general th
eory must incorporate a more inclusive concept of environmental constr
aints on species behaviors than advanced in their proposal, as well as
an expanded account of those behaviors. Our modifications of the orig
inal proposal allow its unrestricted applicability at all scales relev
ant to vegetation dynamics, and emphasize the fundamentally continuous
, interactive nature of these dynamics.