Rh. Clothier et al., THE EVALUATION OF PESTICIDE INGREDIENTS AND FORMULATIONS IN-VITRO ANDCORRELATIONS WITH IN-VIVO DATA, ATLA. Alternatives to laboratory animals, 23(5), 1995, pp. 667-675
Pesticides are often insoluble directly in aqueous solvents, but can b
e dissolved/suspended in surfactant-based formulations. Both surfactan
ts and pesticides can induce irritation. Since a single in vitro assay
has proved inadequate for evaluating the toxicity of a chemical and i
ts ability to cause an irritant response, a combination of assays was
employed to examine the potential toxicities of two pesticide formulat
ions. The surfactant-based vehicles had toxicities that reflected thei
r surfactant concentration. The formulation containing 5% permethrin r
equired a more concentrated vehicle than was needed to dissolve 0.1% c
ypermethrin. In vitro, the ID50 dose (i.e. the dose which inhibited th
e increase in total cellular protein by 50%) was 576 mu g/ml for the p
ermethrin formulation and 1080 mu g/ml for the cypermethrin formulatio
n. This corresponded closely to the ID50 values for the vehicles alone
(464 mu g/ml and 1230 mu g/ml, respectively). When tested at high con
centrations on confluent cells over a 1-minute exposure period to mimi
c potential exposure of the eye, the more concentrated vehicle, Lanoso
l 50 ME, was 4-6 times more toxic than Siege II. Technical grade perme
thrin and cypermethrin had low toxicities in each of the in vitro test
s employed. Taken together, these results reflected the in vivo profil
es available.