Various nasal humidifying agents are being promoted for regular use. I
n this study we compared the effects of three formulations (medium 199
, 0.9% saline and a commercially available isotonic sea-water formulat
ion Rhinomer) on ciliary beat frequency using rat tracheal cilia as a
model. Surface response methodology was used to evaluate the effects o
f pH and osmolality of the formulation on ciliotoxicity. Our results s
howed that none of the formulations differed in their effects on cilia
. Moreover, neither medium 199 nor Rhinomer protected the cilia from t
he effects of drugs (chlorbutol, xylometazoline, azelastine and lignoc
aine) known to be ciliotoxic.