N. Craig et al., CLEARING THE FOG ON THE TYNE - PROGRAM BUDGETING IN NEWCASTLE-AND-NORTH-TYNESIDE-HEALTH-AUTHORITY, Health policy, 33(2), 1995, pp. 107-125
When the internal market was introduced, the National Health Service M
anagement Executive envisaged purchasing as a process by which contrac
ts would be developed from information concerning current services, mo
dified in the light of strategic purchasing objectives, epidemiologica
l needs assessment and indicators of comparative performance and effic
iency, Our concern in this paper is with the promotion of efficiency.
We distinguish between three levels and, in particular, discuss how th
e programme budgeting and marginal analysis framework can be used in t
he promotion of efficiency at 'top-level' decision making. PB/MA can b
e used to give a focus to needs assessment and forge explicit links be
tween individual contracts within a well defined health strategy. The
objectives of the current research and development ongoing within Newc
astle and North Tyneside Health Authority are outlined. The intention
is to achieve programme budgeting which is more responsive to decision
makers' needs and is consistent with the contracting cycle. However,
a number of constraints are expected to impede development. They inclu
de transferability of national and international information; absence
of local information on epidemiology, effectiveness and cost-effective
ness; limitations on the accuracy and precision of programme budgets;
and whether purchasers make strategic decisions based on macro budgets
. The contribution of each of these constraints is explored.