Concrete dams located in northern regions are subjected to severe cycl
ic seasonal temperature variations, which may contribute significantly
to the deterioration of the exposed faces and the long-term degradati
on of strength and stiffness properties. This paper presents a compara
tive study of thermal protection methods that might be used to improve
the durability of concrete dams subjected to freeze-thaw cycles. Firs
t, the thermal, structural, and physical processes that affect the dam
's resistance to freeze-thaw cycles are discussed. The thermal durabil
ity of existing northern concrete dams is then reviewed. Three thermal
protection schemes are presented: (i) insulation membranes applied di
rectly to the concrete facings, (ii) insulation membranes with air spa
ces for drainage or visual inspection, and (iii) insulation made of gr
anular material. Two-dimensional thermomechanical finite element analy
ses of a typical gravity dam located in Quebec are then carried out to
assess the performance of thermal protection systems using different
configurations of insulating materials and exposure conditions, and to
develop appropriate design criteria.