Jk. Christman et al., RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ESTROGEN STRUCTURE AND CONFORMATIONAL-CHANGES INESTROGEN RECEPTOR DNA COMPLEXES/, Journal of steroid biochemistry and molecular biology, 54(5-6), 1995, pp. 201-210
The effect of estrogen structure on the conformation of the complex fo
rmed with estrogen receptor (ER) and the consensus estrogen response e
lement (ERE(c)) has been examined with gel mobility shift assay. Prote
ins in MCF-7 cell extracts formed three distinct complexes with ERE. O
nly the slowest moving complex contained ER as indicated by binding wi
th anti-ER antibodies H222 and D547. This ER-ERE complex displayed inc
reased electrophoretic mobility when formed in the presence of estradi
ol (E(2)) and bound radiolabeled 16 alpha-iodoestradiol. The antiestro
gen ICI 164,384 decreased the mobility of the ER-ERE complex and block
ed the effect of E(2). The results reported here indicate that the pos
ition and location of hydroxyl groups on the estratriene nucleus is an
important factor in determining the mobility of ER-ERE(c) (or a varia
nt ERE) in gel shift assays. The ability of E(2) analogs to cause conf
ormational changes detectable as altered mobility was not directly rel
ated either to their binding affinity for ER or to their ability to ac
tivate E(2) responsive genes. Although several dihydroxyestrogens (est
radiol-16 alpha, 1- and 2-hydroxyestratrien-17 beta-ol) caused an incr
ease in the mobility of the ER-ERE(c), other ligands (estradiol-17 alp
ha, 4-hydroxyestratriene-17 beta-ol, 3-hydroxy estratriene, estratrien
-17 beta-ol and 5-androsten-3 beta, 17 beta-diol) with a capacity for
activating at least some E, responsive genes in MCF-7 cells had little
or no effect. On the basis of these and previously published results,
it can be concluded that specific structure features of estrogens are
responsible for conformational changes of ER-ERE complexes detectable
in gel-shift assays. Furthermore, the identified structural character
istics of the ligand which are required for gel-shift are not the same
as those previously reported to be essential for stimulation of trans
criptional activity of ER.