B. Mccarthy, NOT JUST FOR THE THRILL OF IT - AN INSTRUMENTALIST ELABORATION OF KATZS EXPLANATION OF SNEAKY THRILL PROPERTY CRIMES, Criminology, 33(4), 1995, pp. 519-538
In his controversial challenge to criminologists, Jack Katz argues for
a reexamination of situational factors that precipitate criminal acts
, specifically those that concern crime's sensual dynamics. According
to Katz, people's immediate social environment and experiences encoura
ge offenders to construct crimes as sensually compelling. Although ins
ightful, I suggest that this thesis is limited, specifically as it app
lies to ''sneaky thrill'' property crime. Katz's emphasis on the entic
ements of theft, at the expense of other variables, negates a consider
able body of research and leaves a theoretical hiatus that encourages
explanations grounded in individual pathology. I suggest a revision of
Katz's approach that addresses these concerns. I test this reformulat
ion with models of various stages of sneaky thrill theft The results o
f this analysis affirm that the seduction of theft has an important in
strumentalist component and is influenced by several background factor
s, namely, age, gender, and the strain associated with inadequate econ
omic opportunities.