Jn. Han et al., UNSTEADINESS OF BREATHING IN PATIENTS WITH HYPERVENTILATION SYNDROME AND ANXIETY DISORDERS, The European respiratory journal, 10(1), 1997, pp. 167-176
The breathing pattern of 399 patients with hyper-ventilation syndrome
(HVS) and/or with anxiety disorders and that of 347 normal controls wa
s investigated during a 5 min period of quiet breathing and after a 3
min period of voluntary hyperventilation. The diagnosis of HVS was bas
ed on the presence of several suggestive complaints occurring in the c
ontext of stress, and reproduced by voluntary hyperventilation. Organi
c diseases as a cause of the symptoms were excluded. The anxiety disor
ders were diagnosed by means of an abbreviated version of the Anxiety
Disorders Interview Schedule (ADIS). There was a large overlap between
the two diagnoses. Simply breathing via a mouthpiece and pneumotachog
raph made end-tidal CO2 fractional concentration (FET,CO2) decrease pr
ogressively both in hyperventilators and in patients with anxiety diso
rders, but not in normals. At the start of the measurement the FET,CO2
was not different between patients and healthy subjects. In patients
less than or equal to 28 yrs, the decrease of FET,CO2 resulted from a
higher tidal volume, and in patients greater than or equal to 29 years
from an increase in frequency. After voluntary hyperventilation, the
recovery of FET,CO2 was delayed in patients, due to a slower normaliza
tion of respiratory frequency in females and in older males, and of ti
dal volume in younger males, and also due to less frequent end-expirat
ory pauses. When breathing was recorded first by means of inductive pl
ethysmography (Respitrace), the progressive decline of FET,CO2 seen in
patients was not observed: from the onset of the recording, FET,CO2 w
as reduced in patients. It did not change further when, immediately af
ter ards, the subject switched to mouthpiece breathing. The finding th
at breathing through a mouthpiece induces hyperventilation in patients
and that recovery of FET,CO2 is delayed after voluntary hyperventilat
ion, suggests that the respiratory control system is less resistant to
challenges (mouthpiece or voluntary hyperventilation) in those patien
ts. On the other hand, the lower values of FET,CO2 measured during rec
ording by means of a Respitrace probably result from a challenge, prio
r to the recordings, induced by the fitting of the measuring device to
the patient. This unsteadiness of breathing characterizes patients wi
th hyperventilation syndrome end those with anxiety disorders, but is
not sufficiently sensitive to be used for individual diagnosis.