Dm. Bernstein et al., EVALUATION OF THE BIOPERSISTENCE OF COMMERCIAL AND EXPERIMENTAL FIBERS FOLLOWING INHALATION, Inhalation toxicology, 7(7), 1995, pp. 1031-1058
The biopersistence of three fibers was evaluated using an inhalation m
odel. The fibers studied were man-made vitreous fiber (MMVF) 11, a com
mercially produced glass fiber; Fiber B, a relatively soluble glass fi
ber; and Fiber I, a synthetic stonewool with a high content of alkalin
e earth oxides. Fischer 344 male rats were exposed to a well-defined r
at respirable aerosol (mean diameter of less than or equal to 1 mu m)
at a target concentration of 30 mg/m(3), 6 h/day for 5 days. Following
the end of the exposure period, subgroups were sacrificed at 1 h, 1 d
ay, 5 days, 4 wk, 13 wk, 26 wk, and 52 wk. At sacrifice, the whole lun
g was removed, weighed, and immediately frozen at -20 degrees C for su
bsequent digestion by low temperature plasma ashing. The number and bi
variate size distribution of the fibers in the aerosol and lung were d
etermined. At 1 h following the last exposure, the 3 fibers were found
to have similar lung burdens ranging from 7.36-7.72 x 10(6) fibers/lo
ng with geometric mean diameters of 0.42-0.54 mu m. The three fibers w
ere found to be removed from the lung following the cessation of inhal
ation exposure with half-lives of 8-42 days. In addition, an important
difference in removal was seen between the long fiber (>15 mu m) and
short fiber (>15 mu m) tractions. The long fibers cleared more rapidly
with a T-1/2 of 20, 5, and 7 days for MMVF 11, Fiber B, and Fiber J,
respectively. The dissolution of the long fibers appeared to result in
rapid breaking and disintegration with the formation of short fibers
and particles within the first 24 h. The short fiber fraction had a lo
nger T-1/2 of 46, 10, and 12 days for MMVF 11, Fiber B, and Fiber J, r
espectively. Short fibers have been reported to be phagocytized by mac
rophages and either cleared by ciliated mucous transport or eventually
translocated to the bronchial-associated lymphoid tissue and lymph no
des. The pH of the phagolysosome within the macrophage has been report
ed to be <5. Acellular in vitro studies indicate a slower dissolution
at this pH. The diameters of either the long or short fibers did not c
hange significantly over time, supporting the in vitro observation of
the formation of a leached layer with similar physical dimensions as t
he original fiber. The clearance half-times for the three fibers evalu
ated were considerably shorter than that reported for crocidolite asbe
stos, a known fiber carcinogen, suggesting that these fibers would not
persist in the lung as has been shown to be in the case for crocidoli
te. These results demonstrate that the inhalation biopersistence model
provides a sensitive means of evaluating the critical parameters of f
iber biodurability and clearance in the lung. For the MMVF fibers rest
ed, the longer fibers not only dissolve but also appear to break apart
in the lung, thereby quickly removing the potentially carcinogenic fr
action from the lung.