Jm. Brenan et al., EXPERIMENTAL-DETERMINATION OF TRACE-ELEMENT PARTITIONING BETWEEN PARGASITE AND A SYNTHETIC HYDROUS ANDESITIC MELT, Earth and planetary science letters, 135(1-4), 1995, pp. 1-11
In order to more fully establish a basis for quantifying the role of a
mphibole in trace-element fractionation processes, we have measured pa
rgasite/silicate melt partitioning of a variety of trace elements (Rb,
Ba, Nb, Ta, i-If, Zr, Ce, Nd, Sm, Yb), including the first published
values for U, Th and Pb. Experiments conducted at 1000 degrees C and 1
.5 GPa yielded large crystals free of compositional zoning. Partition
coefficients were found to be constant at total concentrations ranging
from similar to 1 to >100 ppm, indicating Henry's Law is operative ov
er this interval. Comparison of partition coefficients measured in thi
s study with previous determinations yields good agreement for similar
compositions at comparable pressure and temperature. The compatibilit
y of U, Th and Pb in amphibole decreases in the order Pb > Th > U. Par
tial melting or fractional crystallization of amphibole-bearing assemb
lages will therefore result in the generation of excesses in U-238 act
ivity relative to Th-230, Similar in magnitude to that produced by cli
nopyroxene. The compatibility of Pb in amphibole relative to U or Th i
ndicates that melt generation in the presence of residual amphibole wi
ll result in the long-term enrichment in Pb relative to U or Th in the
residue. This process is therefore incapable of producing the depleti
on in Pb relative to U or Th inferred from the Pb isotopic composition
of MORE and OIB. Comparison of partition coefficients measured in thi
s study with previous values for clinopyroxene allows some distinction
to be made between expected trace-element fractionations produced dur
ing dry (cpx present) and wet (cpx + amphibole present) melting. Rb, B
a, Nb and Ta are dramatically less compatible in clinopyroxene than in
amphibole, whereas Th, U, Hf and Zr have similar compatibilities in b
oth phases. Interelement fractionations, such as D-Nb/D-Ba are also di
fferent for clinopyroxene and amphibole. Changes in certain ratios, su
ch as Ba/Nb, Ba/Th, and Nb/Th within comagmatic suites may therefore o
ffer a means to discern the loss of amphibole from the melting assembl
age. Elastic strain theory is applied to the partitioning data after t
he approaches of Beattie and Blundy and Wood and is used to predict am
phibole/melt partition coefficients at conditions of P, T and composit
ion other than those employed in this study. Given values of D-Ca, D-T
i and D-K from previous partitioning studies, this approach yields amp
hibole/melt trace-element partition coefficients that reproduce measur
ed values from the literature to within 40-45%. This degree of reprodu
cibility is considered reasonable given that model parameters are deri
ved from partitioning relations involving iron and potassium-free amph
ibole.