J. Kerbeshian et al., COMORBID TOURETTES-DISORDER AND BIPOLAR DISORDER - AN ETIOLOGIC PERSPECTIVE, The American journal of psychiatry, 152(11), 1995, pp. 1646-1651
Objective: Using an epidemiologic approach, the authors attempt to elu
cidate relationships between Tourette's disorder and bipolar disorder.
Method: Of 205 patients with Tourette's disorder in the North Dakota
Longitudinal Tourette Syndrome Surveillance Project, 15 had comorbid b
ipolar disorder. A subset of the patients with Tourette's disorder had
been included in earlier population-based prevalence studies of Toure
tte's disorder in children, adolescents, and adults. Minimal risk rati
os were calculated for the patients with Tourette's disorder plus bipo
lar disorder by age group (children/adolescents and adults). This info
rmation was used to estimate genetic risk indicators for comorbid Tour
ette's disorder and bipolar disorder. Results: The estimated risk of d
eveloping bipolar disorder among the study group of children, adolesce
nts, and adults with Tourette's disorder was more than four times high
er than the level expected by chance, but this finding did not reach s
tatistical significance. It was indicative of trends, however. Conclus
ions: Comorbidity between Tourette's disorder and bipolar disorder doe
s not appear to be due to chance co-occurrence of the two disorders. A
lthough a genetic mechanism may play a casual role, in the absence of
family studies an explanatory model involving the concept of canalizat
ion of basal-ganglia-mediated dysfunctions is offered. In such a const
ruct, Tourette's disorder would be a likely accompaniment to other con
ditions, including bipolar disorder, whose pathogenic determinants mig
ht channel through neural pathways involving the basal ganglia. The pr
esence of significant developmental disabilities may further enhance f
actors culminating in comorbid Tourette's disorder and bipolar disorde
r.