Religious orientation and psychological functioning were investigated
in an analog study with 83 participants. After completing the Religiou
s Orientation Scale (Allport & Ross, 1967), participants read a contin
uous narrative with three scenarios in which they first committed a di
shonest act, and then felt compelled to confess what they had done. Th
e final scenario contained ct manipulation of grace or no-grace, in wh
ich half of the participants were forgiven for their act and half were
not. Following each scenario, participants were tested for feelings o
f guilt and related behavioral and emotional responses. Intrinsically
religious participants were more prone to guilt, more likely to confes
s their wrongdoing, and more likely to forgive themselves than extrins
ically religious subjects. Guilt was found to have a mediating effect
between intrinsic religiousness and some, but not all, outcome variabl
es. The potentially beneficial consequences of guilt are discussed.