D. Rusinskaroszak et al., SEMIEMPIRICAL TREATMENT OF HYDROGEN-BONDING - THE ACETOIN OXIME CASE, Journal of molecular structure. Theochem, 342, 1995, pp. 33-41
The study presents a comparison of MNDO/M, MNDO/H, MNDO/R, PM3 and HF/
6-31G* calculations applied to the acetoin (E)- and (Z)-oxime stereoi
somers. The obtained results suggest that none of semiempirical method
s accurately model both geometries and energies of the various conform
ers studied. The MNDO/M approach predicts structural characteristics t
hat are similar to ab initio data with respect to the intramolecular O
-H ... O interaction, but yields significantly poorer values for the O
-H ... N moiety. The MNDO modifications (except PM3) often lead to an
overestimation of the intramolecular hydrogen bonding energies and, th
us, reduce the ratio of open (non-hydrogen bonded) structures in the c
onformers. Some stereoelectronic effects predicted by the PM3 method a
re also discussed.